City Blogs: Music Blog

January 18, 2012 at 10:06am

CONCERT REVIEW: Publick Musick

Recommend Blog Post
Total Recommendations (0)

Who can argue with scheduling Mozart for a Sunday afternoon in January? It virtually guarantees music of a lighter palette than the cloud cover outside. A good program begins with the selection of good music.

On the program for Publick Musick's Sunday, January 15, show at Christ Episcopal Church in Pittsford were two of the six quintets of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756-1791), his Quintet in G-minor, K. 516 and his Quintet in D-Major, K. 587. Mozart scored these works for two violins, two violas, and one cello, going against the convention of a quintet being two violins, one viola, and two cellos.

By far, the most delightful of the movements of these two scores was the first movement of the Quintet in G-minor, the "Allegro." The program notes cast this movement as "agitated longing" and "resigned despair," but the sprightly tempo, short swells, and singular notes were far from the notion of "despair" of a Beethoven or a Liszt.

Publick Musick was founded in 1995 and is now directed by cellist Christopher Haritatos and violinist Boel Gidholm. Haritatos is to be commended for his excellent phrasing. His cello had a lovely tone and balanced well against the violins and violas, such that its guiding line could be heard to embody the spirit of the day.

I was not, however, convinced of the interpretation by the first violinist, Jennifer Roig-Francoli, as being entirely Mozart. The G-minor quintet has shades of Beethoven in the "Menuetto-Trio (Allegretto)" movement, Bach in the "Adagio, ma non troppo" movement, and Haydn in the "Adagio-Allegro" movement, making it a piece you could not identify as Mozart with your eyes closed. Even so, I found Roig-Francoli's interpretation too driving and too loud in balance to the other instruments.

In the D-Major quintet, the final movement, "Allegro," was considerably faster than the opening "Allegro" of the G-minor quintet. At the rapid tempo, beauty was sacrificed as the melody notes crowded. Part of the appeal of chamber music is the ability of the notes to be heard through a combination of deceptive simplicity and cultural restraint.

As to the final point on my checklist, Rochester is known to have an active music scene for lovers of "period instruments." But, allow me to make the recommendation that if a musician is going to employ period instruments, please use the opportunity to educate the audience. Considering that I read every word of the lengthy program before the concert started, and considering that Haritatos addressed the audience at the start of the concert, I was left to guess that one or more of the musicians were using period instruments, as the instruments slid out of tune and needed re-tuning throughout the concert.

Comments for "CONCERT REVIEW: Publick Musick" (0)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these reviews. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove reviews at their discretion.

No comments have been posted. Be the first and add one below.

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.

Recent Comments

Cowboy Mouth said:

Thanks for the kind words. Glad you liked the show.

about CONCERT REVIEW: Johnny Winter, Break of Reality, Cowboy Mouth

danielle lallathin said:

My best friend bought tickets to concert in rochester ny. The show was cancelled and we didnt...

about CONCERT UPDATE: Blink-182 canceled

Jay said:

Yes, My Plastic Sun was amazing. It was great to hear an original band from upstate NY sounding...

about CONCERT REVIEW: My Plastic Sun, Mochester, Sinzibukwud, Audio Influx

Peter said:

As a former Yinzer, I would like to say that Pittsburgh has a "H" on the end of it.

about Party in the Park Lineup Announced: Rusted Root, George Thorogood, 7 Walkers

Amy M. said:

It was great to see that many people at Sticky Lips to support My Plastic Sun at their debut...

about CONCERT REVIEW: My Plastic Sun, Mochester, Sinzibukwud, Audio Influx