Back to Opinion

URBAN JOURNAL: Lessons from Newt

Recommend Article
Total Recommendations (0)

Newt Gingrich now stands a good chance of being the Republican presidential nominee. I'm not sure politics can get any weirder than this.

Gingrich is a long way from sewing up the nomination, obviously. But last week was quite a week. And Gingrich's rise - his win in South Carolina, his lead in the Florida polls (at least as of early this week) - is particularly impressive given that Mitt Romney was leading in both states only days before Saturday's South Carolina primary. Gingrich has also been closing in on Romney in nationwide polls.

All this happened despite potentially devastating charges by Gingrich's second wife. And he overtook Romney in the Florida polls despite Romney's support by Florida establishment Republicans and his campaign's presence there - and heavy spending -since last fall.

Part of this was Romney's own doing; he fumbled his responses to questions about his tax returns and the Bain Capital-related layoffs. As several conservative commentators have noted, he should have known he'd be asked about them.

("Both of these topics were big issues not merely in Romney's 2002 gubernatorial campaign, but his 1994 Senate run," wrote Jim Geraghty in The National Review. "How does a candidate get blindsided by 18-year-old handicaps?")

Gingrich is a better debater than Romney, but something else is at work. In his sharp comments, he is identifying with, and giving voice to, the concerns of many white, conservative voters. Those voters bristle at being called racist when they oppose entitlements. And when Gingrich defends his charge that Obama is a "Food Stamp president," Geraghty wrote, he is giving "the fearless, unapologetic rebuke to that thinking they had been yearning to hear for years."

The Wall Street Journal added this: "Since Reagan, Republicans have had a President or nominee who was typically either tongue-tied or timid in defending their policies and principles. With Mr. Obama preparing a re-election assault on those principles, GOP voters understandably want a tenacious advocate. Voters sense that, whatever his other failings, Mr. Gingrich can match Mr. Obama on the issues and won't go down without a fight."

It won't be a surprise if at some point Gingrich flames out, handing the nomination, finally, to Romney. But these early days in the Republican campaign are raising important questions. Among them:

  • Will the 2012 election worsen the divisions among Americans?

Gingrich and other politicians are capitalizing on the feeling among many white Americans that their own economic problems are due to give-aways to African Americans and job stealing by immigrants. Democrats ought to be able to talk about fairness, wealth disparity, and Americans' common bonds - and do it without appealing to voters' baser instincts. But it is harder to get that message across in tough economic times than in good ones.

  • What will the Republican Party be like in the future?

Clearly, hard-core conservative Republicans and evangelicals do not like Mitt Romney. And right now, they are in open rebellion against a candidate they consider a Republican Establishment choice. Are these early-state votes a signal that the rebels are in firm control of their party?

In a New York Review of Books article in late September, when even the Iowa caucuses seemed far in the future, Michael Tomasky addressed that question. "Party establishments typically mitigate the more extreme impulses of the activist bases," he wrote. "But this isn't happening in today's GOP."

Establishment Republicans in Congress are doing things they never would have done until a few years ago, Tomasky said, digging in their heels, for instance, on things they've gone along with before, like raising the debt limit. This is the result of the no-compromise, Tea Party freshmen.

"A key thing to watch for, in determining the future of the Republican Party," Tomasky said, "is whether this no-compromise base becomes a majority within the GOP electorate during next year's primaries."

We're into those primaries now. And next Tuesday, Florida may tell us a lot about where both the Republican Party and the nation are headed.

Comments for "URBAN JOURNAL: Lessons from Newt" (8)

City Newspaper is not responsible for the content of these comments. City Newspaper reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

User Photo

Ken Smith Jr said on Jan. 25, 2012 at 5:16pm

"the feeling among many white Americans that their own economic problems are due to give-aways to African Americans and job stealing by immigrants" Really? I thought most people were angry because the big banks got bailed out and they didn't. If not that, then maybe that the rich like Mitt Romney only pay a 15% income tax rate. If either of those are true, then they would have enjoyed Obama's SOTU address.

User Photo

clint said on Jan. 26, 2012 at 5:38am

47% of working Americans pay no taxes! Tax fairness, spoken of by our President, may well only be the creation of a flat tax, with everyone paying into the system!. Class warfare is no different than racial politics...it is designed to divide, not unite, our country. And, liberal newspaper editorial writers need to look at the message of the President a bit more objectively!

User Photo

Ken Smith Jr said on Jan. 26, 2012 at 8:23am

That's simply because those people make very little money. And half of those that don't pay income taxes (47%) do pay payroll taxes. And of the ones who don't pay payroll taxes, half of them are elderly. Like it or not, some people need help in our system. Some day that might be you or someone you care about. A society can be judged by how it treats its disadvantaged. However, something is wrong when Warren Buffet pays 15% and his office workers pay about double that rate.

User Photo

Troll Whisperer said on Jan. 26, 2012 at 10:03am

Mitt Romney is being taxed at a lower rate than his yacht crew. But to some ideologues the yacht crew evidently has too much money - and Mitt doesn't have enough money. Remind me just exactly who is waging class war; remind me about that "shared sacrifice." Funny how 2001-09 - you know, during the financial rape of the middle class - is now a blank memory for some.

User Photo

clint said on Jan. 27, 2012 at 6:02am

Mr. Smith,

Buffet and Romney do not pay 15% on new earned income, they pay it on invested money income because they paid taxes on the income when it is earned. In actual fact, the rates are substantially higher. Put in a flat tax, that is a good and "fair" solution. Also, TW...shared sacrifice is fine with me...if it is shared, not just shared by some.

User Photo

Troll Whisperer said on Jan. 27, 2012 at 9:19am

"Anyone who claims a flat tax won't increase taxes on the middle class is a liar, and that's the flat truth" - Molly Ivins, 1997

User Photo

rukosini said on Jan. 29, 2012 at 10:55pm

Is is true - that Newt and Santorum can not possibly win - mathematically, because they are not on the ballots of all states? Is it true that the one 2 candidates that can possibly win, mathemicatically; is Ron Paul and Mitt Romney?
If so, when will it be front page news?

User Photo

Mary Anna Towler said on Jan. 30, 2012 at 10:58am

Rukosini: Not true. Gingrich didn't get on the ballot in Virginia, but there are numerous states to go, and in some states - New York included - the filing deadline hasn't even passed yet. In addition: some states don't require their convention delegates to vote the way the state did. And there are Super Delegates - state party chairs, committee members - who can vote for whomever they wish at the convention. Failure to get on the ballot in one or two states may generate bad PR, particularly when the state (Virginia) is a candidate's home state (Gingrich's). But it doesn't ruin the candidate's hopes of winning the nomination.

Leave A Comment

(This will not be published)

(Optional)

Respond on Your Blog

If you have a City Account you can not only post comments, but you can also respond to articles in your own City Blog. It's just another way to make your voice heard.